Auto Insurance

[My 34 Ford]

Please give me some advice on auto insurance. I know that there are only a few insurance companies that insure old cars and that the insurance game changes pretty fast so who are the best companies today? I am ready to start driving my 34 2dr and would welcome your advice. This car will only be driven a few hundred miles at most this year but I want to be sure that I insure with a good company and get the right coverage. Thanks for your advice.

[Vic Piano]

I've been with JC Taylor Insurance for 40 years, excellent coverage, service and pricing.

[4dFord/SC]

Hagerty's good, too. Been with them eight years, and fortunately no claims. However, a friend whose '50 Tudor was t-boned speaks very highly of them--they even paid him for his own time in making repairs.

[Krylon32]

I've got 4 cars insured with Grundy. No claims so can't report on that??

[alv]

have grundy great company had a claim , got an estimate and they sent a check right away, never even came and looked at the car.

[19Fordy]

Sponsored Links (Register now to hide all advertisements)

Originally Posted by alv

have grundy great company had a claim , got an estimate and they sent a check right away, never even came and looked at the car.

Grundy will no longer insure you if you want to insure just one vehicle. You must have several. This has been discussed at length on HAMB. I called Grundy and was told the same thing.

[mike in tucson]

Not necessarily true that few insurance companies will insure your car. State Farm, for instance, insured my 39 Ford at a really cheap rate. HOWEVER, their coverage is not "agreed value" so I would have perhaps lost if the car was stolen while under their coverage. When the car was gone thru, the value increased sharply and I transferred to PHLY (formerly Grundy) with agreed value policy. Talk to your current agent and ask about your situation....if you car is a driver and you dont consider it to be very valuable, a standard policy might be applicable. If you car is worth $$$ (a 34 probably is) call a few of the people in the game and get some quotes.....Haggerty and PHLY give online quotes. Bump the liability up to the max, it is very cheap to do.
Mike

[kp4150]

I'm using Condon-Skelly. Good rates based on agreed value, but restricted to recreational uses -- probably not best for 'daily drivers.'

[Robert/Texas]

I had JC Taylor insurance on my cars for over 20 years. I had one claim with them, the right rear fender on my '34 roadster was bent up badly in a Walmart parking lot and they paid for fixing it without any questions. I changed to Hagerty last year because the rates were about $150 less (6 cars) and they offered free towing insurance (10 miles I think). Last year when I was stranded in a Fredericksburg, Texas motel parking lot during the 1000 mile Texas tour with a bad fuel pump they sent a wrecker out and the man pulled the car backwards onto the wrecker platform so that we could push it into my trailer. The only problem was that at first they said that the car was not covered by my policy as it was over 25 years old. It turned out that the same outfit that serves Hagerty serves my other towing policy (FMCA motorhome insurance) and after this was figured out, all went well. I have since renewed the Hagerty policy.

[Cecil/WV]

I used to have JC Taylor for many years and had one claim that was handled very well. A friend of mine had a '49 Ford that he just finished restoration on last spring and totaled it in early summer. He was insured with Taylor and when he insured it, they tried to get him to get $10,000.00 more than he actually put on it. When they settled the claim, they paid hos son to remove the front clip to better see the damage and then paid him the insured amount with no problem.

I changed to Hagerty in 2008 because of more flexibility in when I could drive my cars and it was a bit cheaper and they insured my wife's 2001 Mustang conv. I have had a windshield and one other claim with them with no problems.

Check them all out and choose the one that sounds the best for your wants and needs.

[31chevy]

I have 3 cars with Hagerty. Friend of mine had his 71 Torino totaled & they gave him the agreed value plus let him keep the car. Nice people to do business with.
Gary.

[Bruno]

Been with J. C. Taylor for 12 years on my 1952 F1 - have never had a claim so I cannot speak to that part but I think their rates and coverages are very good.

[rotorwrench]

Many of those firms were probably started by folks who had been in the insurance business and owned older antique or classis cars. They saw the niche market that was being neglected and moved into the business of old car insurance. When the original owners retire and sell their stock out, the companies that purchase them seldom have the same idea about how to run the program. Many are only purchasing them for the revenue income for a long enough period to transfer it to a different buisness like RVs & motorcycles. They don't continue policy that doesn't bring large profits.

It's the American way, sad to say.

[wspiker]

Hagerty!!!!! You can't lose.

[JM 35 Sedan]

I've been with Grundy for five years. As far back as I can remember the underwriter for Grundy has been Philadelphia Indemnity. Last year I had my first ever claim. They sent a very knowledgeable old car appraiser to assess the damage and write up the claim. I had a check arrive in the mail about three days later. They followed up with a phone call to make sure I was happy with the assessment, the amount of payment, and quality of work done buy the repair shop. I just sent in payment to renew my policy before the end of April. I'm very happy with Grundy and surprised to read the negative comments from other Barner's. Perhaps their policy's are different due to different laws in different States? I presently have just one original/stock early Flathead powered Ford V8 insured with them but may be adding another basically stock 5w coupe (my Avatar car) before the end of 2012.

[Cecil/WV]

I wouldn't buy anything from AARP!!!

[Highboy34]

I've been with Hagerty for about 5 years. They cover a race trailer, road race car and touring sports car, agreed value. No claims, no coverage changes and no problems. But suddenly this year, my rate went up about 6%. I asked why and was told that happened, "in a few states," and that it was just, "... a normal rate increase." Nice people but I was disappointed to see the rates go up.

[sanborn]

Jeff/Illinois----you are correct. The correct term is "Agreed Value". In my case, my cars are street rods---not antiques. And it took a while for their people to understand some very rare pieces(components) we have.

[jimd]

I am also investigating insurance for my ford pickup. Don't want to steal this thread but curious of following question. Do you need to inform the company that insures your daily vehicles if/when you use a 2nd company like Haggerty/Grundy etc for antiques?

Thanks

Jim

[B-O-B]

I don't think it's any of their business who you insure your old cars with. I have 5 cars with grundy(now Philsdelhia Indemnity) & just added my 85 GMC 2500 to the policy for a whopping 33.00. I am also working on a claim for the 32 roadster from last fathers day when I hit a large racoon & dig damage to the right front. I notified them (philadelphis indemnity) when I was in Az & they wanted to send an adjuster out but I told them the car was not with me but in Or. They said they would put the caim in a suspence file & notify them when I got back to Or. I called yesterday as I'm in Or. now & they reopened the claim & said they would have an adjuster call to come view the car. I'm waiting on his call. I asked what was the deal with them & Grundy & she said everything is the same except for customer service & for that to call Grundy. They are still insuring classic vehicles & if I remember Grundy used them to underwrite the insurance they sold.