The Ford Barn

The Ford Barn (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/index.php)
-   Early V8 (1932-53) (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Banjo exle in a model A question (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/showthread.php?t=349246)

luke72 05-18-2025 02:50 PM

Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Hi guys i need help , i have a banjo rear axle and a millworks model T spring in model A rear frame and cross member , now the question how much should be the space between the top axle and frame, because with this spring is very low less than a inch thanks

alchemy 05-19-2025 07:00 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

You are doing hot rod stuff, so you probably should ask this question on the HAMB.

But, I can say that it’s not usual for only one inch of clearance by using a T spring. Is that aftermarket spring made lower?

Kurt in NJ 05-19-2025 07:43 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

With modifications it’s hard to figure what was done,what year banjo axle?— perhaps a later one with perches welded on set too wide and the spring stretched out??
post pictures

Tim Ayers 05-19-2025 07:53 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by luke72 (Post 2389709)
Hi guys i need help , i have a banjo rear axle and a millworks model T spring in model A rear frame and cross member , now the question how much should be the space between the top axle and frame, because with this spring is very low less than a inch thanks

Can you post a picture? I'm assuming you are talking about the spring end. Is the main leaf reversed as well?

With stock shackles, you should be OK. You can check it by pressing down on the spring and watch it go through it's arc. If it doesn't hit, it's fine. If it does, then you need to figure something else out. You don't want it hit the top of the axle bell when it's fully compressed.

luke72 05-19-2025 08:42 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by alchemy (Post 2389794)
You are doing hot rod stuff, so you probably should ask this question on the HAMB.

But, I can say that it’s not usual for only one inch of clearance by using a T spring. Is that aftermarket spring made lower?


Yes this is a model T made as a model A width 2.5 reverse eyes will lower 3 inch the car, if used on top of the axle, i'm using spring behind the axle
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt in NJ (Post 2389799)
With modifications it’s hard to figure what was done,what year banjo axle?— perhaps a later one with perches welded on set too wide and the spring stretched out??
post pictures

It's a 37-40 reat banjo spring behind the axle perch to perch should be 48-49" if. I remember correct, frame is not zded

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Ayers (Post 2389803)
Can you post a picture? I'm assuming you are talking about the spring end. Is the main leaf reversed as well?

With stock shackles, you should be OK. You can check it by pressing down on the spring and watch it go through it's arc. If it doesn't hit, it's fine. If it does, then you need to figure something else out. You don't want it hit the top of the axle bell when it's fully compressed.

Yes that's a model T made to run on model A cross member in the instructions says it works also with spring behind axle that's my case and it's a reverse eyes don't want to notch a fresh boxed frame, i have seen around the rear transverse leaf spring should be 4 to 5 inch travel, i think i'm far from this a lot, but in the weekend i will make some mods and post pictures
Thanks all for the aswers

cas3 05-19-2025 08:55 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

your 40 axle perch is farther apart than A axle by 2 or 3 inches I believe. gonna be tough to get the shackles in place

alchemy 05-19-2025 12:58 PM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

You left out the most important details. The spring behind the axle will lower it a lot, even without the reversed eyes or a T spring. I think you dug yourself a hole, literally. Too low. Put a regular A spring back in it for more axle clearance.

Tim Ayers 05-19-2025 01:58 PM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by alchemy (Post 2389864)
You left out the most important details. The spring behind the axle will lower it a lot, even without the reversed eyes or a T spring. I think you dug yourself a hole, literally. Too low. Put a regular A spring back in it for more axle clearance.

I use a '27 model T rear crossmember and '27 T rear spring with a non-reversed main leaf on a '40 (spring behind) banjo in my AV8 on a '32 frame.

It sits great. In fact, I'm thinking of reverse the main to lower it an 1" more.

30Murray 05-19-2025 09:00 PM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

If your spring is mounted behind the axle, with a stock model a cross member, the axle will not be centered in the rear fender. I think your best fix would be to weld sping perches to the top of the axle, Millworks sells them for this purpose. Worked for my AV8.

Tim Ayers 05-19-2025 09:15 PM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by 30Murray (Post 2389983)
If your spring is mounted behind the axle, with a stock model a cross member, the axle will not be centered in the rear fender. I think your best fix would be to weld sping perches to the top of the axle, Millworks sells them for this purpose. Worked for my AV8.

Ah, yes. Depending what model body he has, the cross member could also be moved back. May have to extend the frame, but can be done.

Your suggestion is the easiest if planning to use the stock rear crossmember location.

luke72 05-20-2025 01:22 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by alchemy (Post 2389864)
You left out the most important details. The spring behind the axle will lower it a lot, even without the reversed eyes or a T spring. I think you dug yourself a hole, literally. Too low. Put a regular A spring back in it for more axle clearance.

yep good point lesson learned with tax shipping and other cost the spring costed me around 1000$ hope with a normal model A spring will clear the problem

luke72 05-20-2025 01:34 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Ayers (Post 2389871)
I use a '27 model T rear crossmember and '27 T rear spring with a non-reversed main leaf on a '40 (spring behind) banjo in my AV8 on a '32 frame.

It sits great. In fact, I'm thinking of reverse the main to lower it an 1" more.

do you have any pics? thanks

luke72 05-20-2025 01:35 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Ayers (Post 2389987)
Ah, yes. Depending what model body he has, the cross member could also be moved back. May have to extend the frame, but can be done.

Your suggestion is the easiest if planning to use the stock rear crossmember location.

my cross member is just point welded i can move when i want the frame is not full welded just to prevent this type of problem

luke72 05-20-2025 02:07 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

https://streamable.com/rebk97

that's my frame it's a mix of 32 34 X member, and front and rear model A cross member

Tim Ayers 05-20-2025 08:27 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

3 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by luke72 (Post 2390016)
do you have any pics? thanks

This is how the car sits with a '27 T rear spring with all the leaves and a non-reversed main using a '27 T rear crossmember. I left all of the leaves in since it is a rumble and my boys do ride back there at times.

petehoovie 05-20-2025 10:50 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tim Ayers (Post 2390079)
This is how the car sits with a '27 T rear spring with all the leaves and a non-reversed main using a '27 T rear crossmember. I left all of the leaves in since it is a rumble and my boys do ride back there at times.

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...7&d=1747747552

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...8&d=1747747552

https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/attac...9&d=1747747552

rich b 05-20-2025 10:55 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by cas3 (Post 2389812)
your 40 axle perch is farther apart than A axle by 2 or 3 inches I believe. gonna be tough to get the shackles in place

Actually, Model A spring over perch width is 49-1/2" while '35-'40 spring behind axle perches are 48" between centers.

cas3 05-20-2025 02:12 PM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Thanks Rich! Keep me inline!

Tim Ayers 05-20-2025 07:01 PM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by alchemy (Post 2389864)
You left out the most important details. The spring behind the axle will lower it a lot, even without the reversed eyes or a T spring. I think you dug yourself a hole, literally. Too low. Put a regular A spring back in it for more axle clearance.

Alchemy:

I run spring behind on my '32 railed AV8 roadster. I've never bottomed out even with my teenage sons in the rumble. My '28 body also overhangs the rear of the frame rails and does not sit on top of the rails. I do have oil filled cheapie shocks in the rear as well.

alchemy 05-21-2025 06:51 AM

Re: Banjo exle in a model A question
 

There’s a lot of difference between the A frame and a 32 frame. The kick above the axle will give enough room with the 32. No room with the flat A frame. My brother ran into the same problem 20 years ago. I think he did a little C notch, but still doesn’t have a ton of room. And, he used a stock A spring.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:01 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.