The Ford Barn

The Ford Barn (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/index.php)
-   Model A (1928-31) (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   Good time to check your fan blades (https://www.fordbarn.com/forum/showthread.php?t=279691)

burner31 04-19-2020 11:44 AM

Good time to check your fan blades
 

If you have the original stamped two blade fan, this may be a good time to check them, just found to massive cracks in two of the bolt holes on the same side, this thing was ready to fly apart.
disaster averted

GerryAllen 04-19-2020 11:48 AM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

when you pull it, how about a picture of where exactly the cracks appeared.

Gerry, Birch Bay Wa

GerryAllen 04-19-2020 11:49 AM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

When you pull it, how about a picture of where exactly the cracks appeared.

Gerry, Birch Bay Wa

burner31 04-19-2020 11:56 AM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

Still having problems with this new computer getting the pictures small enough to attach.
I''l get my Son over here and see if he can figure it out.

burner31 04-19-2020 02:39 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

1 Attachment(s)
I may have figured it out

burner31 04-19-2020 02:44 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

1 Attachment(s)
Test

my4dv8 04-19-2020 03:04 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

While ours is a 4 blade v8 fan it looked exactly like burner31 fan. Its been good for the last 11000 miles . I thought the bearing was a little dodgy , which it was then spied the cracks in two blades Tig Welded the cracks and installed new rivets. Peace of mind .

TerryH 04-19-2020 04:54 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

The warnings have been out for years now.....no one should be using an original fan and just inspecting it once in awhile to see if it is still ok. Why take the risk?

Synchro909 04-19-2020 05:16 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by TerryH (Post 1876732)
The warnings have been out for years now.....no one should be using an original fan and just inspecting it once in awhile to see if it is still ok. Why take the risk?

I agree with that completely. When I got my Phaeton, I knew almost nothing of Model As including this issue. The water pump started leaking badly enough that new packing didn't do the job so I put a new one together. When I took the fan off the old one, I could see where it had cracked, been brazed up and cracked again but I couldn't see the worst cracks when the fan belt was on.. I shuddered and when my hand was again steady enough to do it, I put a new aluminium one on. Now, decades and many tens of thousands of miles later, I still think of this as my lucky escape and the best investment I have made.

Sunnybrook Farm 04-19-2020 05:26 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

I have my original propeller sitting on the work bench, it is a beautiful fan but I am running 3 four blades and a new aluminum propeller. I see that I need to check the four blades. I drove an original across 3 states when I was a kid for a guy, someone had sawed the ends off of a steel propeller fan for some unknown reason but it held together, I don't know what I was thinking other than the guy had a babe daughter.

GerryAllen 04-19-2020 05:27 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

Thanks a picture is worth a thousand words

Tacoma Bob 04-19-2020 05:28 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

I have mentioned this for a long time. My first Model "A" fan flew apart back in 1968. That's 52 years ago. Go ahead and live dangerously.

Chuck Sea/Tac 04-19-2020 07:19 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sunnybrook Farm (Post 1876745)
I have my original propeller sitting on the work bench, it is a beautiful fan but I am running 3 four blades and a new aluminum propeller. I see that I need to check the four blades. I drove an original across 3 states when I was a kid for a guy, someone had sawed the ends off of a steel propeller fan for some unknown reason but it held together, I don't know what I was thinking other than the guy had a babe daughter.

A engineer,Russell Babke(spl), in the Seattle club, who wrote several articles in the 70’sor 80’s, for mafca and I think skinned knuckles, did a data study on fan blades. He cut them down to change the harmonics ect. I’m sure you could find his article somewhere. Possible this was done because of the articles, maybe just because one cracked and the P.O. of your car was just balancing it? Who knows

160B 04-19-2020 07:23 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

2 Attachment(s)
Here are two photos. The first photo shows where the crack starts on the original two bladed fan. The second photo shows the damage done to the cast iron water pump casting. I do not have photos of the damage done to the radiator and the hood.

old31 04-20-2020 05:25 AM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

Burner, good find. You possibly avoided a lot of damage to the car and wallet.

Neil Mylar LakewoodCA 04-20-2020 06:08 AM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

About 30-40 years ago, I drove by a house in Long Beach, California, on a Saturday morning. A guy was working on his unrestored 1929 standard coupe, in his driveway. There was a big bulge in one side of his hood. It looked like an axe blade had come up into the hood. He told me that the fan had come apart several years before, when he was driving. He felt very fortunate that it hadn't happened when he had the hood open. He left the bulge in the hood as a reminder of how lucky he was. I wish I would of had a camera with me. This was way before cell phones with cameras became popular.

Sunnybrook Farm 04-20-2020 06:50 AM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neil Mylar LakewoodCA (Post 1876861)
About 30-40 years ago, I drove by a house in Long Beach, California, on a Saturday morning. A guy was working on his unrestored 1929 standard coupe, in his driveway. There was a big bulge in one side of his hood. It looked like an axe blade had come up into the hood. He told me that the fan had come apart several years before, when he was driving. He felt very fortunate that it hadn't happened when he had the hood open. He left the bulge in the hood as a reminder of how lucky he was. I wish I would of had a camera with me. This was way before cell phones with cameras became popular.

Back in the 70s my uncle lost a blade off of a four blade at highway speed. Shook the whole car and we checked we couldn't find even a scratch on the paint. Somehow that blade got out of the engine compartment without hitting anything, he didn't have splash pans but still they are back a ways from the blades. I never could imagine that one in my mind.

rocket1 04-20-2020 10:47 AM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

Still running original 2 blade fan for 45 years,I inspect it often and it is painted with high gloss black.I never stand near it while running with the hood open.

History 04-20-2020 09:52 PM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

My original looked great until I had it off, multiple cracks. I'm runnng an aluminum fan now by advice from this bunch.

Bob Bidonde 04-22-2020 09:45 AM

Re: Good time to check your fan blades
 

1 Attachment(s)
Why would anyone risk running an original fan with a proven crack history? It's a time bomb! Ford knew it was a bad design back when the Model A was new. There is no way anyone can assess the fatigue life already expended on an original fan.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:02 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.